20. New York City is Marmite
Neda Whitney, Senior Vice President and Head of Marketing for the Americas at Christie's, joins me to talk Metaverse, NFTs, and just all things luxury. Neda has an astounding background in brand storytelling, and has pivoted within her career many times to many industries. We engage in a broad discussion, from how AR/VR has helped the art world with virtual auctions (you can try out pieces in your house using AR!), to NFT sales (Neda worked on the famous Beeple NFT sale), to how NFTs can be used for practical and impractical things. Join us on this journey into art, luxury, NFTs, and the future.
Episode Resources:
Transcript
Welcome to the meadow woman podcast. We address the
Unknown:issues, opportunities and challenges facing women in the
Unknown:development of the metaverse the biggest revolution since the
Unknown:internet itself. Every week we bring you conversations with top
Unknown:female talent and business executives operating in the
Unknown:gaming and crypto industries. Here's your host Lindsey the
Unknown:boss POS, the meta woman podcast starts now.
Lindsay Poss:Hello, and welcome to the meta woman podcast part
Lindsay Poss:of the holodeck media Podcast Network. I'm your host Lindsay
Lindsay Poss:the boss POS and from struggle to success for covering it all.
Lindsay Poss:To returning listeners. Thank you so much for tuning into the
Lindsay Poss:show week after week means a lot to me. And to our new listeners,
Lindsay Poss:welcome. I hope you enjoy. I'm really excited to introduce
Lindsay Poss:today's guests. I've been really looking forward to this
Lindsay Poss:conversation after initially meeting this person. It's just
Lindsay Poss:been so wonderful to dig into their background a little bit
Lindsay Poss:and learn more about what they do. So today on the podcast is
Lindsay Poss:Neto Whitney, Senior Vice President and Head of Marketing
Lindsay Poss:for the Americas at Christie's, which is so cool. Netta Welcome
Lindsay Poss:to the show. Thank you so much for coming on.
Unknown:Oh, it's so exciting to be here. Thanks for having me,
Unknown:Lindsay.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah, just to start off, I would love for you
Lindsay Poss:to give the audience a bit about yourself and your background. I
Lindsay Poss:know we share common career paths with both work and
Lindsay Poss:telecommunication and sexual health education. And then we
Lindsay Poss:both need to jump into tech somehow. So I would love for you
Lindsay Poss:to detail kind of how you got to where you were and what you're
Lindsay Poss:passionate and excited about.
Unknown:Yeah, it's not the most straightforward path into the
Unknown:art and auction world. I will admit, I spent the first 20
Unknown:years of my career in advertising in New York, San
Unknown:Francisco, London and Paris. And I started in San Francisco. It's
Unknown:really traditional and wonderful branding agencies like
Unknown:Interbrand, and made my way to New York and realized I was a
Unknown:New Yorker through and through and worked at multiple agencies
Unknown:in the city. I then met my boyfriend, now husband, and we
Unknown:moved to Paris together. And I worked in Paris in London for a
Unknown:bit. And my last stint was at an agency called RGA. It's an
Unknown:amazing blue chip digital agency. And I got the absolute
Unknown:pleasure and delight on working on such a variety of different
Unknown:kinds of businesses. And I think one of the the most thrilling
Unknown:things about working agency side is if you do it, right, you get
Unknown:to solve some of the most interesting brand problems out
Unknown:there. And you get to learn so much about different industries.
Unknown:It's kind of like your SWAT team, that black ops parachutes
Unknown:in and they're like, this is a problem that we either don't
Unknown:want to tackle or don't know how to tackle. And they like, Call
Unknown:in the agency, and you go in, and I did everything from
Unknown:helping, you know, ESPN, think about the redefinition of sports
Unknown:fandom to you mentioned sexual health and wellness, I worked
Unknown:with Planned Parenthood, which was an absolute gift and
Unknown:privilege, on thinking about how to address the sexual health
Unknown:deserts in middle America and how to get that information in
Unknown:the hands of young women and non binary teenagers who really
Unknown:needed answers that weren't just gossip and resources that were
Unknown:vetted. So we created a sexual health and wellness chat bot,
Unknown:and use technology for good. I had the opportunity to work on
Unknown:augmented reality, I got to help Uber think about how to create
Unknown:loyalty apps for both drivers and riders, which were really
Unknown:different communities that were incentivized by really different
Unknown:emotional loyalty triggers. So such really different amazing
Unknown:projects. I got to work on tippity and L'Oreal and a whole
Unknown:gamut of projects. And I ended my career at RGA. Working on the
Unknown:Verizon business and launching iPhones with them and working on
Unknown:Super Bowl campaigns. It was my first foray into the metaverse
Unknown:way back in the day in 2019, and 2020. And then I got a call from
Unknown:the team at Christie's. And I've been thinking of going client
Unknown:side for a while, you know, it's really exciting to get that
Unknown:phone call and get to solve some of these really hard problems.
Unknown:But I was left a little unfulfilled by not being able to
Unknown:see things from start to finish and to learn, iterate, and I
Unknown:really wanted to be able to, you know, do the whole thing. nose
Unknown:to tail and when I got the call from Christie's it was such an
Unknown:interesting time we were we were and still are in the midst of a
Unknown:global pandemic. I don't know what I get to stop saying. And
Unknown:then it's
Lindsay Poss:also far away. Away.
Unknown:Like how long is a piece of string but it Arden
Unknown:auction is a very IRL scenario you know, everyone's seen those
Unknown:iconic scene. As a people raising the paddles and bidding
Unknown:in the frenzy of people, you know, raising the numbers and
Unknown:you want to see art up close, especially when you're paying
Unknown:millions of dollars for it. And we don't just sell art, we sell
Unknown:diamonds, we sell dinosaurs, we sell sculpture, we sell all
Unknown:sorts of amazing things. But the devil is in those details. So
Unknown:how do you take that experience? And how do you translate that
Unknown:into a digital world when that's the only option you really have.
Unknown:So it was such an interesting time to join the business. It
Unknown:struck a chord for me, you know, I've marketed so many things in
Unknown:my career. But the gift of being able to market these truly
Unknown:priceless one of a kind objects is a gift I wake up every
Unknown:morning thankful for It's so cheesy to say but it's it's the
Unknown:honest truth. So here I am, a year and a bit later, fully
Unknown:immersed in the world of art and auction. And that world of art
Unknown:and auction has taken me so many unexpected places. You know, I
Unknown:think I came into it thinking well, the pace might be a little
Unknown:slower, but maybe that's a welcome change, and I was so
Unknown:unimaginably wrong about the pace being slower. Three months
Unknown:after I joined, we sold an NFT for the earth shattering record
Unknown:breaking price of $69.3 million. It was the NFT price heard
Unknown:around the world that started kind of a tech rocket ship in
Unknown:the art world, which was really exciting. In March of this year,
Unknown:we announced a Marilyn Monroe that we are selling this May in
Unknown:New York at Christie's that is estimate on request, but in the
Unknown:region of $200 million, which will be the most expensive
Unknown:estimate for a painting of the 20th century ever on record and
Unknown:is poised to perhaps become the most expensive painting ever
Unknown:sold at auction. It's been a year and a bit of record
Unknown:breaking moments and fast paced moments, and I wouldn't change
Unknown:it for the world.
Lindsay Poss:Those are awesome stories. So there's a lot to
Lindsay Poss:start with. I do want to point out that when you said oh, I
Lindsay Poss:realized I was a native New Yorker through and through. So
Lindsay Poss:funny because I have the exact opposite experience visiting New
Lindsay Poss:York. I'm like I am a New York City visitor through
Unknown:Yeah, New York is I like to say it's Marmite, you
Unknown:know, you either love it or you hate it. And you know, right
Unknown:away. There's no ambivalence about New York City. And I
Unknown:happen to love the flavor.
Lindsay Poss:Yes. Marmite is a good a good comparison, where
Lindsay Poss:it's like every once in a while you think, oh, maybe I'll try it
Lindsay Poss:again. Maybe it'll be different. But I keep trying anyway. That's
Lindsay Poss:so funny. Well, there's so much to dig into there. One thing I
Lindsay Poss:want to talk about is Christy's pivot to online, just because I
Lindsay Poss:read a statistic that said that during 2020s, one sale, which I
Lindsay Poss:believe is kind of a big event of the year for Christie's if
Lindsay Poss:I'm not mistaken,
Unknown:instead of one sale was a sale that we did in 2020. It
Unknown:was the first of its kind, it was a global relay auction
Unknown:between New York, London, Hong Kong and Paris. And it was a
Unknown:massive virtual undertaking for us.
Lindsay Poss:That's what I was reading about is that 50% of the
Lindsay Poss:works that were auctioned were sold without the buyer even
Lindsay Poss:having seen them, which is a I would imagine a big shift in the
Lindsay Poss:way that the business was run. So can you just tell me what,
Lindsay Poss:what things that you all are keeping moving into the future,
Lindsay Poss:about the virtual auctions? What you learned what, what is maybe
Lindsay Poss:an improvement over the in person experience, or what is a?
Lindsay Poss:I don't know what the word for opposite of improvement is, but
Lindsay Poss:a deeper movement in the virtual experience. Or, as we sort of
Lindsay Poss:maybe emerged from the pandemic, like what are you keeping? What
Lindsay Poss:are you getting rid of? How are you using virtual experiences to
Lindsay Poss:supplement your in person stuff as it picks back up?
Unknown:It's a great question. And it's a great luxury to have,
Unknown:right? Because we we've learned so much from the data that we've
Unknown:received, and the data we've received is shocking in so many
Unknown:ways, and I am a firm advocate of digital. But even I was
Unknown:surprised by the adoption of our client base and how many of our
Unknown:clients are really comfortable with the digital tools and
Unknown:services that we've offered, how many of them are engaging in
Unknown:online auctions, how many of them bid and transact online?
Unknown:Because we're talking about really high price points. When
Unknown:you talk about the one sale, you know, those objects are millions
Unknown:of dollars. They're not a lipstick, they're not, you know,
Unknown:a pair of shoes, they are priceless works of art and that
Unknown:takes quite a leap of faith. And I think some of that leap of
Unknown:faith is the 250 plus years of reputation that Christie's has
Unknown:established Um, and you know, the ability to I've seen a lot
Unknown:of these works of art up close in museums before they reach our
Unknown:hands sometimes. So what can I say? I think what we've learned
Unknown:is the optionality in digital has been a true additive
Unknown:experience for our clients, being able to give them the
Unknown:option to view an auction, in a live stream format that has the
Unknown:same effect as a TV program. I mean, our live streams are award
Unknown:winning, produced live streams, they're not just like one guy on
Unknown:a shaky camera in the back of the room, and being able to
Unknown:provide them that option if they don't want you or can't travel.
Unknown:I think that is that is huge. And I think that is something
Unknown:that our clients are grateful for, and will continue to want,
Unknown:I think, offering them tools like superzoom photography, like
Unknown:augmented reality, the ability to take a piece of art, or even
Unknown:a sculpture, that's huge, and you can't transport it and see
Unknown:what it looks like in your backyard. But with augmented
Unknown:reality technology, you can, I think that's something we won't
Unknown:be walking away from anytime soon. I think we've learned
Unknown:that, you know, II catalogs actually are really valuable to
Unknown:our clients, and from a sustainability perspective are
Unknown:really important to our corporate goals. You know, we
Unknown:don't want to be producing some of these heavy bound books that
Unknown:are behind me that we used to produce all the time, because
Unknown:there are implications on you know, the world that we don't
Unknown:want to continue to perpetuate. So we've, we tried to move to a
Unknown:digital catalog format, which has worked quite well. So
Unknown:there's a lot of things that, you know, we are seeing that we
Unknown:will continue to do, I think, you know, will we be fully
Unknown:virtual in our auctions? No, we're so excited to welcome
Unknown:people back into our auction rooms at 20 Rockefeller Center
Unknown:and King Street and around the world. We had live auctions in
Unknown:the fall last year, they were so much fun to go to. I'm looking
Unknown:forward to our live auctions in May in New York this season. We
Unknown:had folks in our auction rooms in you know, London earlier this
Unknown:year. So I think there's definitely going to be a hybrid
Unknown:approach where we use digital technology to be additive to the
Unknown:IRL experience instead of replacing the IRL experience.
Lindsay Poss:Gotcha. Well, I hadn't thought about, you know,
Lindsay Poss:I feel like as if I personally get lost a lot in the VR side,
Lindsay Poss:and have lost touch with what's exciting about AR. But the
Lindsay Poss:ability to visualize things before you purchase them in home
Lindsay Poss:is really special. I mean, that's, that's a new, that's a I
Lindsay Poss:guess, past three to five, maybe even less than five, maybe more
Lindsay Poss:like two to three years and experience that I can imagine in
Lindsay Poss:the industry, you're and makes a huge difference in the way
Lindsay Poss:clients think about purchasing and what they think about
Lindsay Poss:purchasing if they can sort of place it. Yeah, it's like having
Lindsay Poss:a dressing room for free almost or, yeah, that's
Unknown:that. And you know, we use technology as well. We've
Unknown:done full home walkthroughs and VR, which is really exciting.
Unknown:And we actually we've used hologram technology, which is
Unknown:really exciting. Yeah. In March, we had a frenzies NFT sale where
Unknown:we had the proto hologram machine here in 20 Rockefeller
Unknown:Center. And so people were able to see the NF T's kind of come
Unknown:to life in 3d via hologram technology. So we're always, you
Unknown:know, people think, an auction house and they think, you know,
Unknown:255 years old, and they think, you know, we're not going to be
Unknown:keeping up with the times, but we're really pushing that
Unknown:envelope from a technology perspective. So yeah, we're
Unknown:always experimenting with the new and the latest.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah, so speaking of, I would love to hear more
Lindsay Poss:about how you moved into NF T's and the people sale. And that
Lindsay Poss:was obviously Record breaking and got a lot of news, which I
Lindsay Poss:think a lot of the news it was it was mixed, right? It was good
Lindsay Poss:and bad with a lot of people who are fairly resistant to the idea
Lindsay Poss:of NF T's and digital ownership. But how are you all thinking
Lindsay Poss:about it in on on your side, or the people that are coming in to
Lindsay Poss:the auction houses, I'm imagining that they're excited
Lindsay Poss:about it, which is a good indication that eventually, the
Lindsay Poss:negative press will subside and digital ownership will become
Lindsay Poss:more of a thing in the common vernacular. But I would just
Lindsay Poss:love to hear about how you all got interested in NF T's how did
Lindsay Poss:that happen?
Unknown:Yeah, and so funny enough, everyone knows us for
Unknown:people as our first NF T cell but our first NF T cell was in
Unknown:2020 with a work by Robert Alice, the artist, and there was
Unknown:code in the work and we actually NFT some of the code that was
Unknown:embedded in the work. The people sale though was not even
Unknown:arguably is our most well known and ft sale probably is the The
Unknown:most well known NFC sale, if I might be so bold, and, you know
Unknown:that came came to us through a lot of hard work that the team
Unknown:here at Christie's did, we have an extremely passionate,
Unknown:curious, thoughtful group of specialists who had been
Unknown:researching the space been really curious about the space
Unknown:and engaging with the NF T space. And I think curiosity and
Unknown:engagement and the NF T space are two of the most important
Unknown:tools for success in that space, and really listening and thought
Unknown:that it made a lot of sense. I mean, I think we are primarily
Unknown:at our core about art in all of its format. So whether that
Unknown:format is paint brushes or pixels, we are a platform for
Unknown:great art to come to bear and to succeed. And we just couldn't
Unknown:ignore this groundswell around NF T's. And so we partnered with
Unknown:makers place and we did some digging into this artist people
Unknown:aka Mike Winckelmann. And he was nothing if not prolific, I think
Unknown:his first 5000 days is an opus, where he, you know, created
Unknown:artwork every day for 5000 days. And not only that, but then to
Unknown:put that artwork out there into social media, which is notorious
Unknown:for abject criticism, and kind of bare your soul out there and
Unknown:let people critique you anonymously. I have no idea how
Unknown:he does it, he must have the thickest skin of all of us. And
Unknown:I think, you know, love it or hate it all artists objective,
Unknown:you have to admire the grit that went into a project like that.
Unknown:And we did. And so a group of us came together, and we decided we
Unknown:wanted to move forward with it. And not only do we want to do
Unknown:the NFT sale, we want to do the sale, accepting crypto, which
Unknown:was another yet another hurdle. We never wanted to market to a
Unknown:whole new audience. Even
Lindsay Poss:thought about that. It's so obvious, but Yeah,
Lindsay Poss:completely new system to implement.
Unknown:And I was purchased in eath. And to market it to a
Unknown:whole new group of people. You asked the very thoughtful
Unknown:question, you know, who are the buyers and the buyers for our
Unknown:NFT works of which we sold in 2021? Over $150 million with NF
Unknown:T's. They are overwhelmingly the crypto native audience. They are
Unknown:digital creators. They are not our traditional art audience
Unknown:that has kind of swung the pendulum into the crypto and
Unknown:digital world with a few exceptions. When we sold some
Unknown:Andy Warhol NF T's when we sold some more traditional artists
Unknown:that had dipped their toes into the NFT space. We saw a little
Unknown:bit of crossover, but by and large, they are folks from the
Unknown:from the digital art and NFT space. So we had to market to
Unknown:them, which was a big challenge.
Lindsay Poss:It was going to be my exact question was you as a
Lindsay Poss:marketer, how were you thinking about reaching these folks?
Unknown:Well, it was in the heyday of clubhouse, remember
Unknown:when clubhouse was all
Lindsay Poss:very brief moment in time.
Unknown:I know what it was like, oh my god, we have to be
Unknown:on clubhouse. How are we gonna get channeled? Invited was like
Unknown:the thing. And so we were there. We were on club palace. We were
Unknown:doing clubhouse chats like, you know, a couple of times a week
Unknown:and we were getting invited to different club houses to talk
Unknown:about it. And I just remember when the sale was happening. We
Unknown:were all to did a clubhouse hearing people like live chat
Unknown:about the sale and the numbers that were being breached and it
Unknown:was so exciting. But yeah, we we were on clubhouse we got really
Unknown:engaged on Twitter because that is where our crypto native
Unknown:community is. A few of us are on Discord kind of on different
Unknown:channels. But it's more personally and not like as a
Unknown:firm and we just stay engaged with the community. You know, I
Unknown:do a lot of speaking a lot of our specialists do a lot of
Unknown:speaking we go to NF T and yc and f t now Denver NFT ala like
Unknown:we you know, we get a lot of these conferences and, and
Unknown:panels and make sure that we are out there talking the talk and
Unknown:also helping to demystify what NF T's are so that it's not only
Unknown:accessible to our crypto native NFT collectors, but also more
Unknown:traditional art collectors. I was on a panel at the Aspen
Unknown:Institute not too long ago, which was attended solely by
Unknown:traditional art collectors trying to understand more about
Unknown:the NFT space I think a lot of people are interested in afraid
Unknown:to ask. So you know, making sure we're educating people about the
Unknown:space.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah, not from the art world but from my own
Lindsay Poss:personal world. I have so many friends who are just not
Lindsay Poss:interested in crypto and yet all I know many, many people who
Lindsay Poss:Like Funko Pops, and I came up with a personal rule that if you
Lindsay Poss:own a Funko Pop, you're not allowed to make fun of anyone
Lindsay Poss:who purchases. To me, right? It's, you know, there's there's
Lindsay Poss:a whole, a whole crowd of people out there looking to collect and
Lindsay Poss:be part of a community in various ways and various
Lindsay Poss:expressions, and with everything else moving online, I'm not sure
Lindsay Poss:why that type of community building, collecting, being part
Lindsay Poss:of something purchasing assets wouldn't be also moving online
Lindsay Poss:in some form or fashion. So agree. Yes.
Unknown:And I think and I didn't answer this part of your
Unknown:question, but you mentioned digital ownership. And it's a
Unknown:really important part of the equation, right? Because when we
Unknown:sold to people, and kind of every time we sell an NF, T,
Unknown:someone makes the argument about right, save, right, click Save.
Unknown:Yep. And to that argument, I say, you know, we're selling,
Unknown:Andy Warhol is Marilyn Monroe, it's gonna sell for hundreds of
Unknown:millions of dollars, you can go buy a poster out of it at Barnes
Unknown:and Noble. And they are not the same thing. And so
Unknown:fundamentally, physical, and digital, it all comes down to
Unknown:the question of ownership. And you have to subscribe to the
Unknown:idea that there is something special and important and
Unknown:meaningful about ownership, whether in a digital realm or in
Unknown:a physical realm. And I believe in that. And I think the people
Unknown:that are in the NFT community, believe in that. And not only do
Unknown:they believe in the concept of ownership, but they also believe
Unknown:kind of in this greater Metaverse concept that in a
Unknown:future where we spend more and more of our time in some
Unknown:meaningful way, we digital environment, owning a lot of
Unknown:these kind of digital artifacts will be akin to owning a lot of
Unknown:the traditional artifacts that Christie's is known for selling.
Unknown:So if you own you know, Jean Michel Basquiat when he was an
Unknown:up and coming artist, kind of what you're doing when you own a
Unknown:crypto punk right now, when a small percentage of Yeah, it's
Unknown:still really, really expensive youth but it's only in 20 years.
Unknown:So
Lindsay Poss:I know, it was so silly to me that that, you know,
Lindsay Poss:we've translated so much of our lives online already. I don't
Lindsay Poss:think anyone wants to go back to you know, paper billing and
Lindsay Poss:sending in bills. So why wouldn't other types of
Lindsay Poss:ownership I wouldn't other types of assets, why wouldn't other
Lindsay Poss:types of just community because a lot of NF T communities, I
Lindsay Poss:sort of think of almost like sports teams, you know, you're
Lindsay Poss:you're purchasing an asset, you're becoming part of
Lindsay Poss:something you're talking, you're trading with other fans, you're
Lindsay Poss:discussing us drops, it's so similar to me to any other type
Lindsay Poss:of fandom. And there's collectibles associated with it
Lindsay Poss:the thing with those collectibles associated with any
Lindsay Poss:traditional sports team, a greater instead of buying a
Lindsay Poss:jersey, or you're buying an NFT of something that that team has
Lindsay Poss:created, I can't understand well, I suppose I can sort of
Lindsay Poss:understand the resistance, because there's been a lot of
Lindsay Poss:scammy and scummy things that have gone on. And there's been
Lindsay Poss:unfortunately only press attention on those, I think. So
Lindsay Poss:hopefully, in the next you know, one to five years, the press
Lindsay Poss:attention can can sort of refocus. And people can become
Lindsay Poss:more comfortable with this idea. I think there's just a lot of
Lindsay Poss:negativity surrounding it. It's like, either you take the time
Lindsay Poss:to sit down and know it or you just read headlines and think
Lindsay Poss:there's a lot of scammy stuff happening which there is and
Lindsay Poss:just write it all off whole whole sale hold Full Tilt.
Lindsay Poss:That's the word I'm looking for. So kind of silly. Um, but
Lindsay Poss:anyways, I want to getting back to our discussion. How what is
Lindsay Poss:the balance that you see happening in the future between
Lindsay Poss:digital sales and real world sales at Christie's? As in I
Lindsay Poss:imagined the digital is growing. But do you ever see that
Lindsay Poss:overtaking the real world ownership sales of goods?
Unknown:I do not. And I say that with confidence, based on
Unknown:the fact that you know, I said we did $150 million in NF T
Unknown:sales last year for perspective. We did 7.1 billion in total.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah. We're not there yet.
Unknown:So you know, I think, I think as with anything we sell
Unknown:at Christie's, we will always continue to sell the most
Unknown:covetable, most rare, most exclusive and fts. And I expect
Unknown:that that will still keep us somewhere in the realm of that
Unknown:100 and $50 million mark for the foreseeable future. I'm not you
Unknown:know, if I had a crystal ball, I wouldn't be sitting here. I'd be
Unknown:sitting in my private jet somewhere or on my private
Unknown:island somewhere, but I think Did you know it's gonna take a
Unknown:long long while for NF T's to reach the level of maturation
Unknown:where there's enough of them out there at enough of a price point
Unknown:to capture the tipping point in sales, because I think, not only
Unknown:in masterpiece are but in, you know, jewelry in rare books and
Unknown:manuscripts and old master paintings and Asian art, you
Unknown:know, we do a whole raft of other items that comprise our
Unknown:sales. And so I think, you know, to put into perspective, that
Unknown:100 and $50 million in NFT, sales couldn't be one painting
Unknown:and an evening sale for us at this level. So it's a lot. But
Unknown:it's also a little sometimes.
Lindsay Poss:Right? Well, that's what I'm wondering when I
Lindsay Poss:agree with you, I don't think it's going to be a quite a long
Lindsay Poss:while before you get before digital ownership surpasses real
Lindsay Poss:world goods, I just wonder how quickly or slowly that is going
Lindsay Poss:to grow into a easily noticeable portion, you know, like, when
Lindsay Poss:when does it reach the 1 billion mark, or the 2 billion mark? Or
Unknown:what I would say is, I think there's over don't quote
Unknown:me on this, but I think there's quite a large amount of sales, I
Unknown:want to say over a billion dollars of sales being
Unknown:transacted on the other platforms like nifty gateway,
Unknown:open sea and the rest of it. So I think digital ownership is
Unknown:quite a expansive marketplace, I would just say that at the top
Unknown:echelon, yet and established volume, because we're we're
Unknown:dealing with a volume of art that has been established over
Unknown:the last, you know, I would say 500 years to go around rare art
Unknown:and object, I think there is a huge volume of NF T sales in the
Unknown:hundreds of millions, if not billions happening. But that's
Unknown:at all levels. And at Christie's we're only ever to transact at
Unknown:the top level.
Lindsay Poss:That makes sense. I'm wondering when that economy
Lindsay Poss:is going to, it's already developing. But I'm wondering
Lindsay Poss:when it's going to get out of its nascent stages, just because
Lindsay Poss:we also have a lot more people who are a lot more connected in
Lindsay Poss:ways that are conducive to building an NFT economy. More so
Lindsay Poss:than you know, we've talked about 500 years, but there
Lindsay Poss:wasn't necessarily a huge cadre of highly talented artists,
Lindsay Poss:either, you know, you were talking about maybe the top
Lindsay Poss:point 2% of art and artists out there. And I'm just I wonder how
Lindsay Poss:that's going to work with all of us being digitally inclined now.
Lindsay Poss:And especially younger generations? Like how quickly
Lindsay Poss:you know, instead of taking 500 years, I wonder if it'll take
Lindsay Poss:100 Or yeah, 150, or what that's gonna look like. But I want to
Lindsay Poss:get more into this sort of supply problem. Because I saw a
Lindsay Poss:recent listing about the sale of an NFT of the first edit to
Lindsay Poss:Wikipedia, immediately following its establishment. And that
Lindsay Poss:featured interactive element that allowed the purchaser to
Lindsay Poss:recreate the experience of developing Wikipedia, which I
Lindsay Poss:thought was so cool. And I thought it was pretty neat that
Lindsay Poss:the NFT outsold the original computer that Wikipedia was
Lindsay Poss:created on. I think that does make sense in terms of Wikipedia
Lindsay Poss:as a digital products of the digital good would outsell a
Lindsay Poss:physical good. But it's still it's still interesting to note
Lindsay Poss:that the digital good did markedly better than the
Lindsay Poss:physical good. And we've seen similar in FTAs. You know, Jack
Lindsay Poss:Dorsey's first tweet, sold, the New York Times article, it was
Lindsay Poss:part of an experiment sold as an NF. T. So we talked about this
Lindsay Poss:volume problem, what kinds of different things are you excited
Lindsay Poss:to see? So we we definitely have art and artwork as a type,
Lindsay Poss:definitely have this sort of like, I don't know exactly how
Lindsay Poss:to call it but tech bookmarking? That's sort of a type of NFT.
Lindsay Poss:But are there any other ones, you know, partners with luxury
Lindsay Poss:fashion brands? Or? I don't know anything? Is there anything out
Lindsay Poss:there that you think like, oh, I can't wait until this sort of
Lindsay Poss:becomes a digital good or I'm really excited to see the way
Lindsay Poss:this digital good develops?
Unknown:Yeah, that's a great question. So we sold that NFT of
Unknown:Wikipedia for 750 grand and that was that was that was Biglan it
Unknown:was really exciting. What I can't wait to see NF T is my
Unknown:COVID vaccination card that I carry around little scraps of
Unknown:paper everywhere. It's like everyone has that important
Unknown:papers or where it's like your social security card and like
Unknown:your it's like do not laminate but we all like you know, live
Unknown:in fear of losing it and it's like my marriage certificate, my
Unknown:kids birth certificates like, you know, all these forms that
Unknown:are just like tattered pieces of paper that I use. usually end up
Unknown:having to pay the government to issue me a new one because I've
Unknown:lost it lives in our special paper drawer. I can't wait to
Unknown:see all of those become digital goods on the blockchain. I think
Unknown:there are a number of different applications out there that we
Unknown:haven't even scratched the surface have we sold last year,
Unknown:our first luxury NFT that was in the form of an NF T of the
Unknown:bulletproof vest that Kanye West wore during his live performance
Unknown:of his Donta album or toe into that space. But I see luxury
Unknown:brands are really leaning into Metaverse, specifically when it
Unknown:comes to gaming. Because there's already user behaviors built in
Unknown:there right? In gaming, people are already really comfortable
Unknown:with the purchase of goods and services in gaming. They're
Unknown:really comfortable with the idea of skins in gaming. And so to be
Unknown:able to kind of like up level that into a luxury. A luxury
Unknown:skin makes total sense. And I think luxury brands are starting
Unknown:to catch on to that there's like going to be a Metaverse arm to
Unknown:Fashion Week. experiments going on that I think will be really
Unknown:interesting. Um, and, you know, there's been lots of great
Unknown:applications for sports fandom and sports memorabilia and NF
Unknown:T's. What am I I think for me, I'm I'm most looking forward to
Unknown:the utility aspects of it.
Lindsay Poss:I believe that answer? Yeah, I
Unknown:think, you know, like, there's fun stuff out there. And
Unknown:like Ray and I have like, some NF T's in my wallet that have
Unknown:kind of promised this ongoing membership aspect that it's like
Unknown:once you have access to this initial token, kind of all of
Unknown:our drops and subsequent builds, you will have access to and
Unknown:that's exciting from like a kind of like mystery grab bag
Unknown:perspective. And like I'm part of a community and I don't
Unknown:really know how it's gonna evolve. But I'm, I bought into
Unknown:it, that's exciting. But utility, like, Give me something
Unknown:that instead of holding, like all these membership, papers, I
Unknown:can just have it on the blockchain never have to think
Unknown:about it again. That's, that's, that's what will make this girl
Unknown:happy.
Lindsay Poss:That's so funny to me. Because one of the things
Lindsay Poss:that I worked on, or that I one of the people that I talked to
Lindsay Poss:at a previous job was about cartitles, and putting them on
Lindsay Poss:the blockchain to make the sale and transfer of cars
Lindsay Poss:significantly easier. For everyone involved. Yes, I also
Lindsay Poss:am looking forward to the utility aspect. One of the early
Lindsay Poss:people that I followed, we started really talking about the
Lindsay Poss:NFT space in 2019. And mentioned the exact same thing about
Lindsay Poss:marriages as well imagine call recording your marriage and
Lindsay Poss:blockchain instead of having to send in a marriage license. So
Lindsay Poss:yes, I do think that there is a huge practical side that is
Lindsay Poss:untapped. And I heard someone describe this as a, what could
Lindsay Poss:be considered a boring transition into web three, and
Lindsay Poss:to how we think about our online presence and to how we collect
Lindsay Poss:and use digital goods should be probably a little bit more
Lindsay Poss:boring than the current news suggests. I agree. But I like
Lindsay Poss:you hope that all those practical matters that can be
Lindsay Poss:addressed by this technology begin to get addressed with this
Lindsay Poss:technology. I want to backtrack for just a second, though,
Lindsay Poss:because we had a previous call where you talked a lot about
Lindsay Poss:your work ethic, and where your background, your family, where
Lindsay Poss:you came from, and how it made a big impact to you to think about
Lindsay Poss:you being in the position you're in and being a role model for
Lindsay Poss:other younger girls and women who may not have always seen
Lindsay Poss:people who looked like you. And I know that you mentioned that
Lindsay Poss:you didn't see very many people that looked like you in the
Lindsay Poss:positions that you have been in, and will continue to be in. But
Lindsay Poss:I wanted to address that really quick because this is the man or
Lindsay Poss:woman podcast. So I wanted to just ask you what it's going to
Lindsay Poss:actually look like, you know, we have all this future tech, all
Lindsay Poss:this exciting stuff. But how are we going to make sure we start
Lindsay Poss:truly diversifying the workforce at all levels and getting more
Lindsay Poss:role models in there and getting more people involved?
Unknown:Yeah, I mean, it's so important, Lindsay, and I think
Unknown:my parents were immigrants to this country. And you know, I
Unknown:think that that is such a special journey and such a
Unknown:special part of my story and a part that I always tell people,
Unknown:I am, you know, just celebrated the Persian New Year in March,
Unknown:and I celebrate my culture, and it's something I have two young
Unknown:girls that I'm gonna raise them with as well. And I take I take
Unknown:pride in that. And I want everyone from any walk of life,
Unknown:whether it be cultural diversity, whether it be you
Unknown:know, gender diversity, whether that be, you know, whatever it
Unknown:is not however you identify, to feel like there's a path for
Unknown:you, and to feel like you have an authentic place in
Unknown:leadership. And so, for me, I heard someone say it so
Unknown:beautifully. I was on a panel for a National Women's Day. And
Unknown:the woman on the panel with me said it's simple In a model
Unknown:messiness, and I could not agree with that more, I think it is
Unknown:not something that we can just pretend that our lives fit into
Unknown:these neat little boxes. And that I'm working at a and that
Unknown:at home. I'm mom Mehta, and I'm wife Neda, and I'm Iranian,
Unknown:American meta, and I'm, you know, all these different
Unknown:versions of that I am all those versions of meta wrapped into
Unknown:one ball. And I think I'm at my best when all those versions of
Unknown:meta come to the party. And so I try and be as authentically me
Unknown:as I can. And I try and encourage those around me to be
Unknown:as authentically them as they can by modeling that messiness
Unknown:by saying, You know what, I gotta go, I told you, I need to
Unknown:leave this, this podcast a few minutes early, because my
Unknown:parents are in town, and I want to go show them the gallery
Unknown:downstairs. And that's really important to me. So I gotta go
Unknown:do that today. And you know, I'm going to be really excited about
Unknown:that and proud about that. And some days, I need to leave a
Unknown:meeting early to go pick up my kids because I need to show up
Unknown:as mom Netta. And then I hopped back on a call later on that
Unknown:evening, because I gotta be working at and, you know, it's,
Unknown:it's all a part of who we are. And I think modeling that
Unknown:messiness, instead of trying to pretend there's any attainable
Unknown:perfection is really important. And then I think when you see
Unknown:those women around you, letting them be comfortable and
Unknown:confident with them, talking about that messiness, and then
Unknown:also celebrating them and promoting them. Like, I don't
Unknown:just want to like high five ladies, I want to give ladies
Unknown:raises, I want to give ladies opportunities, I want to give
Unknown:ladies speaking roles I want to give ladies, like, you know, all
Unknown:of those great things that people saw in me that helped me
Unknown:get to where I am, I want to give those opportunities to
Unknown:people, because it's one thing to say, like I celebrate you,
Unknown:but it's another thing to say, You know what I'm gonna sit this
Unknown:pitch out. And I'm going to pull my colleague into this pitch,
Unknown:because she's got a really powerful voice that I know that
Unknown:if you guys see that you will see her in a different light.
Unknown:And that's actually doing something with my voice instead
Unknown:of just saying she's great.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah, I think that's so important. I think
Lindsay Poss:it's important to because, unfortunately, we do sort of
Lindsay Poss:carry the burden sometimes of forcing attention onto our
Lindsay Poss:female colleagues, and especially women of color. And
Lindsay Poss:this is a theme that's come up over and over, but it does take
Lindsay Poss:bravery for people to look and listen to people who don't look
Lindsay Poss:like them. It takes a lot of it takes bravery to step outside of
Lindsay Poss:your comfort zone. And it takes the wherewithal to realize when
Lindsay Poss:you need to do so. And sometimes having that extra push of like,
Lindsay Poss:paying attention time is the push that's necessary. So yes, I
Lindsay Poss:love, love the idea of standing up for women. And I hope as we
Lindsay Poss:move into more of a Metaverse and, and NFT, VR, and AR all
Lindsay Poss:those spaces that we can have more women creators, and writers
Lindsay Poss:and in positions of power and all of that. Well, with that in
Lindsay Poss:mind, I know you have to run soon. So I'm going to just
Lindsay Poss:quickly summarize our conversation. We started with an
Lindsay Poss:awesome, awesome discussion about how Christie's has moved
Lindsay Poss:into online, just so cool. I mean, the whole, I have not been
Lindsay Poss:this close to the luxury auction industry in my life. So
Lindsay Poss:extremely fun for me to learn about that and to learn about
Lindsay Poss:how you all adapted during the pandemic. And some of the
Lindsay Poss:virtual tools that you're gonna wind up keeping in your arsenal,
Lindsay Poss:like VR and AR experiences is really neat. Especially think
Lindsay Poss:it's cool that you can use AR to model some of the things that
Lindsay Poss:people might be purchasing in their own homes. It's very, very
Lindsay Poss:intelligent use of the technology. We also talked a lot
Lindsay Poss:about NFT sales. One thing that I thought was really interesting
Lindsay Poss:was about how it kind of brought in a completely different crowd
Lindsay Poss:for you to market to, as it were, and how it's a crowd of
Lindsay Poss:full of cryptocurrency natives, so not necessarily the typical
Lindsay Poss:art crowd, but definitely a little bit different. And now
Lindsay Poss:you're getting some cross contamination between the
Lindsay Poss:typical art and the crypto natives and back and forth,
Lindsay Poss:which is pretty neat. We also talked about how NF T's can be
Lindsay Poss:used for practical and impractical things, which I
Lindsay Poss:think is really important to note. There's a lot of
Lindsay Poss:negativity surrounding the technology itself, when really
Lindsay Poss:the options are pretty boundless at this point, so I think I
Lindsay Poss:think I can confidently say that both of us are pretty excited to
Lindsay Poss:see what happens within the NFT space in the next 510 20 years.
Lindsay Poss:And the last thing we talked about was making sure that we
Lindsay Poss:boost women colleagues, it can be hard, I'm in some of the
Lindsay Poss:environments we're in for women to get attention. So we have to
Lindsay Poss:not only talk about it, but be about it and put women forward
Lindsay Poss:for things when they have earned and deserve it. So I like to end
Lindsay Poss:every episode with one special section called a moment of
Lindsay Poss:reflection. It's just a chance for you to look back on your
Lindsay Poss:career. offer any pieces of advice you might have to women
Lindsay Poss:who are looking to take the same nonlinear path that you did, or
Lindsay Poss:are in bits and pieces of it. But what is one thing you would
Lindsay Poss:like to tell your younger self about getting into the tech
Lindsay Poss:industry and being successful? It's
Unknown:not specific to tech, but I think just specific to
Unknown:life, there's two pieces of advice I would give my younger
Unknown:self and everyone's younger self. The first is take the
Lindsay Poss:risks,
Unknown:I think, you know, women tend to be more risk
Unknown:averse. And we tend to take the safer path, myself included. And
Unknown:there's lots of rewards and the risks and you do regret the
Unknown:risks you don't take. And right now I see so many different and
Unknown:interesting paths to success. If you take NF T's for an example,
Unknown:that is not a linear and traditional path to financial
Unknown:success, but those who are taking those risks are finding
Unknown:oftentimes success. And I want those risk takers to also be
Unknown:women. Much like the traditional art world, it is a highly white
Unknown:male worlds in the NFT space. And so there are so many lovely
Unknown:female led projects, you know, you have archived from world of
Unknown:women, Lisa from Boss beauties, you know, Varvara, les from
Unknown:flowergirl, NF T's. They're amazing projects out there, but
Unknown:they are few and far between. And we have more female voices
Unknown:and NF T's, or whatever it is take those risks. And the second
Unknown:thing I would say is you are the CEO of your own career, no one
Unknown:is going to be a better advocate for what you need than you are.
Unknown:So anytime you can speak up for yourself. Ask for the raises,
Unknown:ask for the opportunities, have a voice at the table, you don't
Unknown:ask you don't get. And you know, I think it is really important
Unknown:to push beyond that discomfort of an initial ask into an
Unknown:uncomfortable conversation that can result in a better
Unknown:opportunity, more pay more chances, more ways to grow, or
Unknown:at least the acknowledgement that you're ready for that next
Unknown:step. And it's really, really important to be a vocal advocate
Unknown:for your own career. Because no one else out there is going to
Unknown:do it for you, as well as you can do it for yourself. There
Unknown:might be people out there advocating for you. But no one's
Unknown:going to do it for you better than you can. So be your own.
Unknown:See.
Lindsay Poss:Yeah. I love that. Thank you so much for coming on.
Lindsay Poss:Where can people find you follow you follow your work, follow
Lindsay Poss:Christie's
Unknown:my instagram handle is super complicated. It's my
Unknown:maiden name. It's at NAMM Iranian and a m i RANIAN. But
Unknown:that's where all my good content is. And I would love for anyone
Unknown:to follow me there and see all the great stuff we do at
Unknown:Christie's see all the great stuff I do with my passion and
Unknown:my girls and my life. And that's where all the good stuff is. And
Unknown:please feel free to DM me. I'm always happy to grab a coffee or
Unknown:have a chat with anyone who's trying to find their path.
Lindsay Poss:Oh, thank you so much. For all of our listeners.
Lindsay Poss:Be sure you leave those five star ratings and reviews. Check
Lindsay Poss:out other holodeck media podcasts including meta business
Lindsay Poss:and the business of esports. I'm on Twitter, Instagram and
Lindsay Poss:LinkedIn at Lindsay at Lindsay POS. And you can catch me
Lindsay Poss:Wednesday nights on the business of esports live after show. This
Lindsay Poss:podcast will be in your feed every Tuesday. We'll see you
Lindsay Poss:next week.
Unknown:Thanks for joining us here on meta woman. Make sure to
Unknown:subscribe to this podcast everywhere you get your
Unknown:podcasts, leave a five star review and tell your friends,
Unknown:family and colleagues all about us. Also, make sure to follow
Unknown:metta TV on all socials to get more of the best Metaverse
Unknown:content anywhere. Tune in every week for another episode of